| 2009 |
| Maturity Limit | by Abigail Corrado |
| Frustration | by Erik Crouch |
| Charlotte Ablaze | by Emily Patten |
| The Bus Stop Chronicles | by Brenna Sansom |
| Textbookland | by Andi Wang |
| Halfway Decent Living | by Tyler McCarthy (Honorable Mention) |
| 2008 |
| Standing Ground | by Shannon Burke |
| The Ivy League | by Casey Corrado |
| The Hollow Voices | by Stephanie Del Rosso |
| The Invention of 0 | by Deepali Gupta |
| An Aspiring Insomniac | by Katie Butta (Honorable Mention) |
| Five Fridays in February | by Hannah Utt (Honorable Mention) |
| 2007 |
| Fall Apart | by Galen Danskin |
| What First Amendment? | by Sam Graebner |
| Out Of This World | by Russel Moore |
| 2006 |
| The Process of Blurring | by Aine McCarthy |
| I Think It's Monday | by Jon Skalski |
| Wallflowers In Bloom | by Vanessa Willoughby |
|
